Can I use 400 amp AC breaker instead of class T 400 amp fuse - Page 2
 

Can I use 400 amp AC breaker instead of class T 400 amp fuse

Started by centrix29, September 07, 2007, 06:12:01 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Len Silva

I would say that chances are 99 out of 100 that you will never blow that fuse and it is certainly much less expensive than a CB.  When a 400 amp fuse blows, you will know it and so will all the neighbors.

Len

Hand Made Gifts

Ignorance is only bliss to the ignorant.

NJT5047

Another reason for manufacturers recommending fuses over circuit breakers may be the speed at which they open.  A fuse is much faster. 
Large DC Circuit breakers are expensive in comparison too. 
JR
JR Lynch , Charlotte, NC
87 MC9, 6V92TA DDEC, HT748R ATEC

"Every government interference in the economy consists of giving an unearned benefit, extorted by force, to some men at the expense of others."

Ayn Rand

Dallas

Pat,
The Xantrex setup that I've read requires a T-fuse.

Mostly the reasoning behind it is that the T-fuse is nearly fast enough to possibly save the electronics in the inverter. Breakers aren't.

Do it your way, but if it's a new inverter under warrantee, I would put the fuse called for in it. It might make your case for replacement a little more tenable.

Just my way...

Dallas

Sean

Wow, lots of speculation on here from folks who, apparently, have not even read the documentation for your inverter before telling you why you can't do certain things.

So that I don't make the same mistake, perhaps you can tell us the model and voltage of your inverter?  After all, Xantrex makes the manuals for all their inverters available on-line.

FWIW, my own Xantrex inverter manual says nothing at all about preferring a fuse over a breaker.  It does, however, stipulate that the maximum allowable fuse is 400A, whereas the maximum allowable breaker is 250A.  While this may seem like a big difference, the fact is that the 250A breaker will provide better protection for your wiring, batteries, and inverter, and will only be a minor inconvenience if it ever trips, while the class-T fuse will likely be a real project to change.

Xantrex, BTW, will be happy to sell you their own branded 250A DC breaker for this purpose.  If you can get by with 200A, Square-D's QO-series breakers carry DC ratings, and there is a two-pole model available in that size, available at almost any home center for a reasonable price, with a two-pole enclosure commonly available for around $15.

I have a 400A class-T (actually, two of them, since I have separate 24volt and 12volt feeds off my battery bank).  I figure that if it ever blows, I have bigger problems than how hard it is to change the fuse.  Also, the fuse holder takes up less room than a circuit breaker and enclosure.  Lastly, my cables are four-ought, and getting cables that big into the panel and onto the lugs is a challenge. YMMV.

-Sean
http://ourodyssey.blogspot.com
Full-timing in a 1985 Neoplan Spaceliner since 2004.
Our blog: http://OurOdyssey.BlogSpot.com