Buying used appliances vs new ones

[Oregonconversion]

I have heard that if I buy older RV appliances (80s) like fridge, furnace, and AC units that they have a better chance of lasting a long time once all the bugs are worked out.

Is this true? or should I buy a new furnace and 2 way fridge?

[Lin]

Old ones are obviously cheaper but the reliability comparison usually has to do with pre-circuit board equipment.  That would really require you get something that is very, very old.  That compromises the reliability right there.  If you can afford new, you will be better off.

[Oregonconversion]

OK thanks for that. makes sense.

So one for buy new. Any others?

I should have done a poll.

[Oregonconversion]

how old do I have to go to have no electronics?

[TomC]

Gas stoves are still built the same way.  You can still buy roof top A/C's with mechanical thermostats (the kind with the controls in the ceiling unit). I bought a 9cu/ft NovaKool 12v/120vac compressor refer that has a mechanical thermostat (about the same cost as a absorption type refer). Same with the Splendide washer/dryer. The propane furnaces do have simple control boards-but are reliable.

I would buy new appliances-something about having new and knowing you're the first to use it.  Good Luck, TomC

[artvonne]

  The only truly good RV appliances ceased to exist in the early 70's. Having said that, Magic chef still seems to build okay gas ranges, Atwood still seems to know how to make a water heater, and thats about it. Suburban and Atwood RV furnaces are junk. New Dometic and Norcold absorption refrigerators are junk too. Tom is right on about the fridge and AC units.

  I would only buy used if it was such a good deal it was equal to almost free. Most all this stuff we have to cut holes and build around, its not worth installing junk.   

[bevans6]

I look at it as everything is used once it's been used the first time...  But knowing the history is priceless.  If you buy a used RV, or a project bus halfway done, you are getting used appliances.  If you buy a house, it probably comes with five used appliances.  My bus had a new fridge (when the PO built it, so it was used to me), a used hot water heater, a new stove top, a used furnace.  I kept most, fixed all the installs (not one was done right, or even close) and bought a new oven/cooktop and rooftop AC from a bankruptcy clearance sale from a local RV store.  So I go either way.  I make decisions based on the unit in front of me at the time.

Brian