hub meter hours
 

hub meter hours

Started by MCI-RICK, April 02, 2011, 04:37:40 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

MCI-RICK

How many hours on a hub meter mean it's time for a rebuild? The bus is a 1986 TMC 102A3 with a 6V92TA and the hub meter shows 13,816 hours. ???
Aim high but look out below

jhaggerty

Rick,

I'm pretty sure all hub meters read miles or kilometers, not hours. I could be wrong.

Jim

MCI-RICK

I thought so. I've asked the seller for clarification on the post.
Aim high but look out below

trucktramp

Hub meters measure distance traveled via revolutions of the axle that it is mounted on.
Hobbs meters measure time.  They used to be seen on some aircraft and farm implements.
Hope this helps.
Dennis Watson
KB8KNP
Scotts, Michigan
1966 MCI MC5A
8V71
Spicer 4 Speed Manual

thomasinnv

HUB meters are usually installed due to some type of overhaul, but could be for a myriad of reasons.  Without some type of documentation showing why that particular meter was installed it's kind of useless.  Could have been a minor in-frame, could have been a full replacement. Your guess as good as any.
Some are called, some are sent, some just got up and went.

1998 MCI 102-DL3
Series 60 12.7/Alison B500
95% converted (they're never really done, are they?)

Lin

Thomas, some buses, like mine, have hubometers because there is no odometer.
You don't have to believe everything you think.

luvrbus

Hub meters don't mean much they need to match the rpm of the tire to be accurate and guys changing tire sizes throws it all out of whack some have dip switches to set the rpm and some don't


good luck
Life is short drink the good wine first

Dave5Cs

A mechanic told me that they have a box of them in the back and when they would do overhauls etc. they would put on a new one and throw the old one in a box. They would give them away to whom ever might need one no matter what the number were. Most of them ended up with someone selling a Bus or truck that looked like it had lower miles on them. He also stated that they can be changed pretty fast. FWIW
"Perfect Frequency"1979 MCI MC5Cs 6V-71,644MT Allison.
2001 Jeep Cherokee Sport 60th Anniversary edition.
1998 Jeep TJ ,(Gone)
Somewhere in the USA fulltiming.

Runcutter

If it's measuring hours, I think Dennis had it right --- it's a Hobbs Meter, not a hubodometer.  We have a Hobbs meter on the auxiliary generator of our 4107.  

However, back to the original question, does a Hobbs meter, or Hubodometer, indicate that a rebuild is imminent?  I think not, for two reasons.  As mentioned, we don't know whether work has been done, without the meter being reset -- thus, it could be the total hours on the engine, regardless of whether it's had a minor.  Second, time or mileage alone don't necessarily indicate a rebuild.  Was the coach maintained well -- longer life.   Was the oil never changed (after all, Detroits drain their own, so we only have to add make-up oil) - then it may already be overdue.  

If we use an average of 50 MPH (don't know the type of service over the coach's life, local/highway ratio, so 50 may be a good guess) - AND if it's the original engine -- AND if nothing's been done on it, then we could estimate that something has about 700,000 miles (690,800).  Is it the bus?  Is it the engine?  Sounds like we'd have to guess.    

So, let's add to the question -- what would an oil analysis tell about the state of the engine, and whether it's time to start the piggy bank for a rebuld?  What other diagnostics would answer the question, as to the probable health/longevity of the engine?  Also, is the consideration whether to budget for a rebuild, actually do a pre-emptive rebuild as preventative maintenance based of failure predictability, or is this a prospective coach purchase - and a price/value question?

As much as I appreciate the airlines doing rebuilds based on predictability of future failures, I wouldn't take that approach with a personal land vehicle (fleets, yes, my own cars/bus, no).    

Arthur
Arthur Gaudet    Carrollton (Dallas area) Texas 
Former owner of a 1968 PD-4107

Working in the bus industry provides us a great opportunity - to be of service to others

MCI-RICK

The seller said it's an hour meter. I asked where is it located and I'm still waiting for a response
As usual, lots of good info hear :)
Aim high but look out below

MCI-RICK

Ok,  I finally got it straight.

It's a dash mounted engine hour meter. Sorry bout that ???

The hour meter shows 13,816.

What does that translate to in miles?

Is that too many hours?  ???
Aim high but look out below

Runcutter

Rick, it'd also be helpful to know the history of the bus - original fleet owner, subsequent owners, whether it's ever been run by a church, etc.  I've never seen an hour meter in a coach (mostly firetrucks, as I understand), so it would be interesting to find out who would put one in.  Disclaimer, it's been over 35 years since I did much with coaches -- I've specialized in transit since the mid/late 70's.  Interesting aside, transit uses hubodometers/mileage for PM's, although hours might be just as good.  

Edit - I just saw your additional post.  If you know much about the original/subsequent uses of the bus, multiply the hours by a reasonable MPH assumption.  In my earlier post, I suggested 50 MPH, giving you about 700,000 miles on something -- but, again, we don't know if an in-frame was done, if other work has been done, or if it's even the original engine.  It could even be that there was a replacement/overhaul, and the Hobbs meter wasn't reset -- again, because most bus work is done based on mileage, not hours.

Arthur
Arthur Gaudet    Carrollton (Dallas area) Texas 
Former owner of a 1968 PD-4107

Working in the bus industry provides us a great opportunity - to be of service to others

Hi yo silver

Rick,
On my bus, which is a professional conversion, the hour meter on the eyebrow panel is for the diesel powered generator, and not the bus engine.
Dennis 
Blue Ridge Mountains of VA   Hi Yo Silver! MC9 Gone, not forgotten

MCI-RICK

The bus has been church owned for quite a few years.

They bought a new bus to replace the older one.

No problems with it but it is an older bus and they don't want to experience breakdown on one of their interstate trips.
Aim high but look out below

artvonne

   The hour meter only indicates the number of hours the current to the meter has been engaged. Youll have to determine what it indicates, engine or generator. Without paperwork that says when it was installed, thats all that it means. If the engine or Gen had reciepts saying such and such was done at such and such hours, you would have something to go by, provided the meter has been operational the entire time.