Radiator Trivia

[Burgermeister]

Happycampersrus posted:

How does the fan air pressure affect the aeration of the engine coolant?   It doesn't - two separate things.

If you check the air flow with a manometer, How can that tell you if your coolant is aerating?

I'm talking about checking aeration within the coolant, as it circulates with a special type of manometer setup.

So as not to confuse by the above,  I have spoke in the past about checking pressure differential "drop", between the radiator core and the fan, within the shroud, using a different (i.e., traditional) manometer setup.

[Burgermeister]

Reply to Ace,

If I make it, I'm coming, once again, by airliner, with RJ Long and hopefully Bob Sheaves. 

The desire is to give the improved presentation of  "All you never wanted to know about cooling systems and were afraid to ask! Seminar, originally given in Rickreal at Bus'sUSA 2006.

The manometer setup is a testing device inserted in the "stream" of coolant and used to see if conditions favorable to the propagation of coolant aeration exist.

There's too many variable factors to allow someone to "look" at my bus and figure what "their" bus needs or doesn't need.

I ain't retired and, frankly, don't want to take enough time off to drive a bus to Arcadia just for Bus'n 2007.

The stuff I talk about is simply the proper application of proven technology.  Some of it borrowed from other disciplines.  If I can't explain my points adequately, there's no reason the presence of my bus will make a difference.  Any set-up can be "tricked"  witness the various mileage claims or fuel from water scams - etc..

With taking anything away from you or other builders - rightly proud of your collective work, I'll complete my bus, my way, in my own time.  It's for me - not for seeking "Look what I can do" attention. 

It'll be awhile, should I live long enough, before my bus gets completed and to the East Coast.

Marc Bourget

[DrivingMissLazy]

The following link is a good writeup on coolants and problems experienced with different situations which may be of interest. Especially with those that have engines with sleeves.
The article discusses aeration very briefly with the following statement:

"Maintaining electrical grounds is an essential aspect of cooling-system maintenance, because stray electrical currents can cause problems in cooling systems. Regularly check ground connections for the batteries and starter, and be careful to properly ground any add-on accessories.

On the other hand, aeration in a cooling system can cause problems that are sometimes blamed on stray currents. Periodically inspect the cooling system for air leaks from loose clamps, bad hoses and bad pressure cap."[/b]

At least to these writers aeration is not a common problem and it is caused by air leaking into the coolant system. This was the only reference to aeration I could find in the article.

I have to admit that in my many years of dealing with heavy equipment, very large engine generator sets and very large luxury yacht engines I had never before heard of any problem with aeration.

Here is the link:
http://www.constructionequipment.com/article/CA6256027.html

Maybe this one works:
www.constructionequipment.com/article/CA6256027.html

Sorry, neither link seems to be working at the present time so I will just paste the writeup here.
Richard

http://www.constructionequipment.com/article/CA6256027.html

Prevention Illustrated

The Basics of Diesel-Engine Coolant

Or, a few tips that may help you stay out of cooling-system trouble in a world that's working against you

September 1, 2005
By Walt Moore, Senior Editor


Elizabeth Nelson, coolant program manager at Polaris Laboratories, a fluid-analysis company in Indianapolis, Ind., tells a story that would strike fear into the heart of any fleet manager. A class-8 on-highway truck seemed in fine condition when it left the West Coast, but at the end of its 6,000-mile cross-country run, a cylinder sleeve failed and catastrophic engine failure resulted. According to Nelson, the cause of the disaster was an electrical short in the truck's starter.

"An electrical short in a vehicle takes the path of least resistance to ground," says Nelson, "and often that's through the cooling system. In this instance, the electrical current passing through the coolant so quickly depleted the nitrite additive in the antifreeze, that the sleeves no longer had protection against cavitation. When coolant analysis shows a rapid depletion of nitrite, coupled with an increase in nitrates, it's always a red flag for an electrical short."

A combustion-gas leak, on the other hand, says Nelson, causes a sharp drop in pH (usually below 7) and an increase in sulfates. Air leaking into the cooling system, however, typically results in a lowered pH, she says, (but usually not below 7.5) and a drop in nitrite level (but not as rapid as with an electrical problem).

What's in the radiator?
Although regular coolant analysis is a good way to keep tabs on the health of a vehicle's coolant system, coolant analysis is not nearly as popular as oil analysis. For many equipment owners, truth be told, what goes on in their machine's cooling system is somewhat of a mystery.

"Ask most fleet managers about their lube-maintenance programs, and they'll talk in detail," says Craig Gullett, brand marketing manager for Old World Industries, a major antifreeze manufacturer. "Ask about their coolant-maintenance programs, however, and more often than not, answers become rather uncertain."

A frequent weak link in coolant maintenance, and the probable cause of many coolant-related engine problems, says Carmen Ulabarro, coolants market development specialist for ChevronTexaco, is the lack of understanding about what coolant is being used in the vehicle — and how to maintain that specific formulation.

Virtually all heavy-duty antifreeze is roughly 95 percent ethylene glycol and 5 percent water and additives. The stuff that isn't made from ethylene glycol (only about 1 percent of all antifreeze sold) is made from propylene glycol, which is less toxic, but also more expensive. "Coolant" is created when glycol is mixed with various ratios of water. Typical ratios range from 30 to 60 percent glycol.

Heavy-duty antifreeze formulations differ from one another by virtue of the additive package blended into the ethylene glycol. Additive packages, of course, all have the same task, namely to fight rust, scale and corrosion — and in diesel engines, to protect wet cylinder sleeves from cavitation. But the additive packages among various antifreeze formulations have fundamentally different chemical fingerprints.

Until maybe 15 years ago, heavy-duty engines typically were filled with "conventional" antifreeze, identified by the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) standard D-4985. This antifreeze, however, which is still in prevalent use today, can't be used in diesel engines without first treating it with a "supplemental coolant additive" (SCA) that contains nitrite for protecting wet sleeves. The required initial treatment is an approximate 3-percent concentration of SCA (one pint per four gallons of cooling-system capacity).

Today, the preferred conventional antifreeze for diesel engines is "fully formulated," identified as ASTM D-6210 or RP-329 by the Technology & Maintenance Council (TMC). This antifreeze is sold with an SCA package already blended in, typically including nitrate to protect iron and steel, tolyltriazole to protect copper and brass, borate or phosphate to buffer acids (formed as glycol breaks down), silicate to protect aluminum and nitrite (sometimes accompanied by molybdate) to form a cavitation-resistant barrier on sleeves.

These additives are depleted as the coolant works and ages, however, and must be replenished periodically with an SCA package. Especially critical is the renewal of an adequate nitrite level. But you must be careful here, because too much nitrite may cause solder corrosion, and excess accumulation of other additives causes "total dissolved solids" (TDS) to increase, possibly jeopardizing cooling efficiency and resulting in passage-clogging dropout. Cautious maintenance guidelines may suggest replacing fully formulated conventional coolant at two-year intervals to avoid TDS problems.

To simplify maintenance, the antifreeze industry developed "extended-life coolants" (ELC), which are formulations typically advertised with a service life of 600,000 miles or 12,000 hours. These formulations, originally at least, replaced the additive package used in fully formulated conventional antifreeze with "organic-acid inhibitors," designed to protect metal parts by forming a thin protective skin against destructive forces in the coolant.

These "organic-acid-technology" (or OAT) antifreezes use the base or neutralized version of organic (carbon-containing) acids, typically (but not always) the carboxylate acids of 2-ethyl hexanoic acid (2-EH) and/or sebacic acid. Most heavy-duty carboxylate formulations, however, also contain some of the additives used in fully formulated conventional antifreeze, namely nitrite and molybdate, and sometimes silicate. OAT formulations that include nitrite sometimes are called nitrited-organic-acid-technology antifreeze, or simply a NOAT.

According to some antifreeze experts, anytime you add inorganic inhibitors (like nitrite) to an organic-acid-based formulation, you have created a hybrid, or a Hybrid OAT, or a HOAT. Others say, though, that a hybrid is technically a product characterized by the use of non-carboxylate acids, such as benzoate, from benzoic acid, another organic acid.

Maintenance
To ChevronTexaco's Ulabarro's point, the start of good coolant maintenance begins with knowing which antifreeze formulation is in your machine's radiator.

Most NOAT formulations, for example, require the addition of an "extender" at 300,000 miles or 6,000 hours to replenish nitrite, which is used up at a far slower rate in an extended-life coolant than in a fully formulated conventional. Important to note here, perhaps, is that European engine manufacturers are evaluating — maybe even leaning toward — the use of carboxylate-based extended-life coolants without nitrite.

Don't buy into the philosophy, however, that extended-life coolant needs no regular maintenance. The experts recommend inspecting it at the vehicle's regular maintenance intervals to make sure it's clear (no rust), that the color is right (not mixed with another antifreeze type) and that it has sufficient freeze/boil protection, best determined by using a refractometer.

Maintenance guidelines for cooling systems with fully formulated conventional antifreeze typically include periodic testing of SCA levels and appropriate adjustment, as well as periodic draining, flushing and refilling the system to avoid, as already noted, an excess of dissolved solids.

You can test the additive concentration of fully formulated conventional coolant by supplying samples to a fluids-analysis laboratory. Or, you can do the testing yourself by using paper test strips, which are chemically sensitive and change color to indicate freeze/boil point (glycol content), nitrite (or nitrite/molybdate) levels and, in some instances, pH.

When the addition of an SCA is indicated, keep in mind that two major types of SCA are available, one with a nitrite/borate formulation, the other with a nitrite/molybdate/phosphate formulation. It's probably best not to mix them, and it's best to use a test strip designed for the specific formulation. Those in the know say to be careful about buying bargain-priced SCA formulations, which may be inferior. Look for a stated compliance with an ASTM standard on the package, likely D-5752, to ensure that you're buying a quality product.

Some users of fully formulated conventional antifreeze, however, employ a coolant filter charged with an SCA package. This filter/additive assembly is designed to release metered amounts of additives over time and, thus, to maintain optimum levels. As long as testing indicates proper additive levels, and provided that top-up is done with a 50/50 mix of the correct antifreeze and deionized water, the assumption is that fully formulated conventional coolant can last far longer than the often-prescribed interval of two years.

On the other hand, says ChevronTexaco's Ulabarro, some users of fully formulated conventional antifreeze drain and replace coolant every year, but do not test or add SCA packages between those service intervals, thinking that nothing will go wrong in that short time. But, depending on the specific formulation of the antifreeze and on top-up practices, says Ulabarro, critical additives could be depleted in as little as 1,000 hours, potentially leaving the engine virtually unprotected for a long time.

In the everyday world, of course, fully formulated conventional and organic-acid antifreezes are sometimes inadvertently mixed in cooling systems. The primary concern about a mixed system is that the distinctively different additive packages in the two formulations will be diluted to the point that neither has the power to afford adequate protection. You're best off, say the experts, to pick an antifreeze type, take all practical safeguards to avoid mixing it with other types, and conscientiously follow the maintenance strategy recommended for the chosen antifreeze.

Coolant Analysis

Given the changing chemistry of coolants and the increased demand placed on cooling systems by today's engines, Bryan Debshaw, CEO of Polaris Laboratories, believes that coolant analysis will become an increasingly important tool in preventive-maintenance programs. Coolant analysis not only determines coolant condition, he says, but also identifies other vehicle problems that can show up in the cooling system. Coolant-analysis programs typically are available in various levels (and costs), depending on the number of parameters checked.
A primary cause of wet-sleeve damage is cavitation, but other causes are prevalent: these sleeves have been attacked by 1) stray electrical current going to ground through the coolant; 2) calcium and magnesium scale that impedes heat transfer and is caused by water with minerals (the sleeve "blues" at 600F); and 3) chloride (in the water), which "decarbonizes" iron until it is like sand, says Elizabeth Nelson of Polaris Laboratories

Quick Tip
Using tap water in your vehicle's cooling system can undermine your best efforts at good maintenance if it creates rust, scale and corrosion. Premixed coolant, with 50 percent demineralized water, avoids these problems. So does deionized water. Talk to your local water-conditioner expert about a deionization unit. We found a local supplier who would install a "mixed bed" unit for around $200, then switch tanks as needed for $80 or $90. Typical tank life is 1,500 to 2,500 gallons of treated water.



If you use paper test strips to check the condition of fully formulated conventional antifreeze, make sure the strips are fresh and designed for the type of coolant being tested. Remember that freeze-point readings may be unreliable if glycol levels are above 60 percent.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.


Wet-Sleeve Cavitation

In a wet-sleeve cooling system, antifreeze additives create a barrier between the engine's sleeves and the small bubbles that form in the coolant next to the sleeves, the result of pressure differentials. When the normal vibration of the sleeves causes the bubbles to implode, they do so with great violence and can create tiny cavities in the surface of unprotected sleeves. Left unchecked, this "cavitation" process (a leading cause of engine failure) can create holes in the sleeves and allow coolant to leak into the cylinder. Fully formulated conventional antifreeze uses nitrite, which coats the sleeves, to protect against cavitation. Organic-acid-technology antifreeze uses chemicals that plate sleeves with a thin protective layer, but these formulations also may contain nitrite.

Illustration adapted from Baldwin Filter graphic.


Conversion Possibilities

Manufacturers of at least three brands of organic-acid-technology antifreeze have programs for converting cooling systems from fully formulated conventional coolant to an organic-acid-type coolant, without draining and refilling the system. Reduced maintenance is cited as the primary benefit of conversion.

ChevronTexaco's Fleet Fix Conversion, Shell's Extended-Life Coolant Conversion, and Old World Industries' Final Charge Converter can be used to make the conversion, but the existing coolant must meet specific parameters before conversion can proceed. (Old World Industries' Final Charge antifreeze is a non-carboxylate organic-acid-based product that contains no nitrite.)

By contrast, Penray, a maker of antifreeze additives, promotes a "Fill-for-Life" strategy, which is aimed at converting nitrited-organic-acid-technology coolants to fully formulated conventional coolant. Penray's conversion strategy employs its Need-Release Filter, which uses corrosion-sensitive barriers for the timed release of SCA charges.


Electrical Grounds and Aeration

Maintaining electrical grounds is an essential aspect of cooling-system maintenance, because stray electrical currents can cause problems in cooling systems. Regularly check ground connections for the batteries and starter, and be careful to properly ground any add-on accessories.

On the other hand, aeration in a cooling system can cause problems that are sometimes blamed on stray currents. Periodically inspect the cooling system for air leaks from loose clamps, bad hoses and bad pressure cap.
  Posts: 355 | Location: UK | Registered: 27 May 2001 

 

[Happycampersrus]

Ok Marc,

I think I know what you are describing now. I was confused by your post on Sept, 29th. It refered to "cooking system delta p". I had never heard of such a thing and it took me a little time to put it together. That post coupled with your post on Sept, 27th asking David if he had access to a manometer to check his fan threw me off.

Dale

[Burgermeister]

Happycampersrus.  Sorry I wasn't more clear!


Richard,

I apologize for not defining what I meant by aeration.  It's not what it would seem to the lay person.

By Aeration I meant the generation of bubbles in the system caused by Internal Restriction in coolant flow, irrespective of external leaks allowing entry of air into the cooling system

Entry from external sources during operation probably only occur from combustion products, cracked head/bad head gasket, etc.  To much pressure to work against. 

Fact is, at elevated temps the partial pressure of the coolant will approach the system pressure.  Restriction to flow in the system may result in a drop in pressure at various points in the system, most notably the intake to the coolant pump.  The pressure differential is sufficient to drop the pressure below the Partial Pressure, introducing "Aeration" thru boiling.  There are other mechanisms for adding air, with DD 2 strokes, the fact that they have "built in" air traps in the heads that contribute to the problem. 

Aeration is quite common but is usually dealt with by responsible design  of the cooling system.  It rears it's ugly head with repowers, improper driving techniques or modifications to the system, 

Onward and Upward

Marc Bourget

[Ace]

Guys I wasn't trying to "call anyone out"! I was merely asking for HONEST simple answers to questions that some of us, (other than myself) have always wondered about!


Later Gator... and yes, we all DO still get along!

[Dallas]

Thanks Ace.

Dallas

[Burgermeister]

BB members



Partial pressure is a % figure indicating, on a scale of 1-100%  how "close" a fluid is to boiling at that temperature.

At Std temp and pressure (sea level) water is supposed to boil at 212 degs. F. (14.7 #/sq in) At the higher pressures of a closed cooling system 5 psi some busses to 21 psi in some cars,  Temps close to 200 deg are say 90% partial pressure (for example 13.23# in a pot of water on the stove).  The fluid  won't boil until the temp goes higher or,  if you have a good coolant pump and some restriction in the radiator, hoses, thermostats, whatever,  the pump, at the inlet, will "suck" ( to use an improper term) the pressure down until it is lower than the example of  13.23 #/sq,  the partial pressure now exceeds the boiling pressure (at sea level) and bubbles will form.  (This is like water in Denver will boil at less than 212 deg. F)

[Keep in mind,the actual boiling point in a bus cooling system will be higher since it's under pressure.  I just picked the sea level figure to give some numbers for example purposes.]

The problem is, because of surface tension effects (the thing that "enables" or makes bubbles) once the bubbles form, and go to the high pressure side of the pump,  the higher pressure alone, isn't enough to collapse the bubbles. The higher pressure will make the bubbles slightly smaller, but they won't go away as easy as they're formed..  These "tiny bubbles" act as insulators and also, by their presence, reduce the "mass" of the coolant available to take the heat away.

Got to use special "tricks" to get the "stubborn"  bubbles out of the coolant. 

But this is part of the "All you wanted to know" seminar so I'll drop it at this point.

HTH

Marc Bourget

[Busted Knuckle]

BB members

Recognizing Bryce's comment - that I get too technical and "lose" the attention of readers,  I offer the following.
But this is part of the "All you wanted to know" seminar so I'll drop it at this point.

HTH

Marc Bourget

Marc I didn't mean to offend you, and it's not all of your posts you lose me on. But I am a simple ol' counrty boy who all the way from like 1st grade(or B4) couldn't understand alot of things "unless I was able to actually get a hands on experience" and also didn't understand why I needed all that crap as all I wanted to be was a truck driver! (LOL) Then I became interested in working on vehicles and had pretty much the same attitude, until they started computerizing cars (then I was lost! and I quickly put my tools in storage and went back to my first passion of driving trucks!) Thinking "After all they can't computerize trucks after all it's a DIESEL all it needs is fuel air & compression!" Boy was I ever wrong! LOL!  So please don't take offense, I'm sure that everything you say is true and correct! But I get lost in all that long winded stuff, and quite frankly even if it ain't long if I can't actually get in there and "see/feel" what it is I'm still lost! I did stay in school long enough to graduate from High School (my mothers wish!). But after that it was schools out for me! I have the utmost respect for anyone who betters themselves by continuing or returning to school, it's just not for me! And to those of you who did continue and get degrees and such, congratulations and THANKS after all it's those of you who help idiots like me survive even if we don't understand most of what ya say! BK 

[Nick Badame Refrig/ACC]

OK Guy's

This is where I step in and clean everything up..

Man, I didn't want to read this thread but, here I am.....

Let me know if I missed anything.

Nick-