They are selling this for about $200. Does anyone know if it's any good?
TRUCK LUG WRENCH TORQUE MULTIPLIER NO IMPACT OR COMPRESSOR NEEDED (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5Ctp89AH58&feature=player_embedded#ws)
Lin,
I dunno about the one shown, however I can vouch for the X12 torque mulitiplier. It does a great job, is compact and I believe safer than a 4' cheater bar.
Works for me, courtesy of PO so I can not advise on price, other than it lists for $650 or so. http://times12.com/wrench.htm (http://times12.com/wrench.htm)
Gary
Last time this came up, people who had them allowed as how the worked exactly as advertised. Which is a pretty good recommendation, when you think about it. Now, I don't have one but I do remember the conversation.
Brian
I wounder how they would work on a dayton wheel. I doubt that it would fit with the dish.
My last bus had Dayton wheels. They were not torqued down as much as these are. If you need a multiplier, you could probably go with a straight multiplier ratchet.
That's awesome Lin Iam thinkin I need one of those
I am considering it if I go for replacing those suspension bumpers. Otherwise, since I won't have a really need for it right away, I will find myself loosening and tightening lug nuts just for fun. I don't know that I want to sink to that level yet.
Lin, that one that you posted the video of is the other one that i told you about. I did show you my X12 didn't I?
If it works as advertised then it would be something worth having. Trouble is that so many items advertised do not work as promised or hold up very long. Maybe someone who actually has one will chime in.
Ed,
I like that one you have, but $200. sounds better to me than $600. If this works for the rare occasions I would use it, it could be good enough.
I purchased the one Lin pictured.........it works great! At a 60 to 1 ratio 7.5 lbs in = 450 lbs out. It sure beats jumping up and down on a 5' breaker bar and busting your shins. This is so easy to use I'll have to hide it from the wife!
I have one of those also, it is much heavier than it looked so it is pretty rugged.
I haven't found a nut yet I couldn't loosen with it.
Be careful about using it to install nuts though, you can really over torque with that thing. As I remember it can go up to 7000 lb-ft just with the included handle!!
I have a TIA X12 and it works as advertised. I have never needed it because I have a 4 ft pipe and a 4 way lug wrench ;D. I will list it in the Spare Tire. Take a look and PM me if you want it.
John,
A big advantage I found for the multiplier over the 4-way is I don't need the 4-way outboard support any more.
Gus
I know.... old habits are hard to break. If the nuts and the wrench are good, I can do it without the jack stand.
On another note.... I don't know where Ashflat is but we are southbound through AR, starting tomorrow. We are going through Branson and Little Rock and I don't remember the rest of the route because I'm not lookin at my Streets and Trips. Are you anywhere near Little Rock??
John,
Ash Flat is on Hwy 167 just south of MO. It is quite a bit east of Hwy 65, the route you would normally take from Branson to LR.
From here it is about the same distance to either LR or Branson on a dog leg route.
I will be here until Fri and back on Monday. Let me know your plans.
Gus, Sorry I have missed you.... we are in Mcghee south of Pine Bluff.
Lin, My apologies for hi jacking your thread.
John
I bought one and it came today. It works wonderfully if you turn it in the right direction. I forgot the lug I tried it on first was left handed. Fortunately I realized the error before I stripped the stud. I will use 8# on a torque wrench to tighten up. It would be very easy to go to far with this.
Lin,
These things are designed for loosening nuts but they are not very accurate for torquing. It is real easy to over torque with them. If it is like mine you can easily reach 1000 lb-ft.
You might want to check some of your torquing with a torque wrench just to make sure.
Gus,
My torque wrench is really only good for up to 150 foot pounds. I had thought that with a 60:1 rating, I could set the wrench to 8 ft/lbs and be within reason. Do you think that this would not work?
a torque wrench that is normally used to do up to 150 ft lbs is going to be horribly inaccurate at 8 ft lbs. Each 1 lb error is going to be 60 ft lbs error after your multiplying by 60 times. I would expect that your wrench, set for 8 ft lbs, will return somewhere between 5 and 10 and you'll never know which... why not just use it to undo things, the way it's supposed to be used, and do the nuts up the old fashioned way? 4 foot breaker bar and lean on it?
Brian
Quote from: bevans6 on October 25, 2010, 08:17:43 PM
a torque wrench that is normally used to do up to 150 ft lbs is going to be horribly inaccurate at 8 ft lbs. Each 1 lb error is going to be 60 ft lbs error after your multiplying by 60 times. I would expect that your wrench, set for 8 ft lbs, will return somewhere between 5 and 10 and you'll never know which... why not just use it to undo things, the way it's supposed to be used, and do the nuts up the old fashioned way? 4 foot breaker bar and lean on it?
Brian
This plus the fact that torque multipliers also have frictional loses (usually specified by the manufacturer) so you can add that to the mix and X it to your torque wrench's inaccuracies.
Lin,
A 3/8 torque wrench in inch-lbs will be more accurate but I don't think that will help much as per the above posts.
You can use your 150 lb-ft torque wrench with an extension to bring it up to 450-500 by using a little math. All you're doing is extending the length of your wrench handle, kind of a cheater bar effect.