BCM Community

Bus Discussion => Bus Topics ( click here for quick start! ) => Topic started by: AJ on June 13, 2010, 10:32:08 AM

Title: Tire Temperature
Post by: AJ on June 13, 2010, 10:32:08 AM
Ever since I got my infrared thermometer I have been measuring my tire temperature, on the steer, drive and tag at, side wall and thread.
My question is;
On a hot summer day driving, say 92 degrees ambient air, black top highway, 60 to 70 MPH, what are the expected normal tire temperatures?

AJ
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: Ed Hackenbruch on June 13, 2010, 11:42:58 AM
Also add in tire pressure to the equation and don't forget that the sunny side will be warmer than the shady side. :)
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: Bob Belter on June 13, 2010, 12:09:48 PM
Ahoy, AJ,

I've seen my tires --  sunny side --  95f day at 125f -135f, less down-sun.  I'm light @ 33,000# running 90psi main and drive, 80 psi tags.   
At rest stops, I've spotted 18-wheelers with higher and lower temps --   I'd guess loaded or empty.  Some smaller and heavier trailers were above 150f.

Enjoy   /s/   Bob
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: JohnEd on June 13, 2010, 02:18:18 PM
90 degrees ambient.  Surface of the black top is going to be 140....as a guess.  I have been in 140 saunas and all was OK but I can't walk barefoot on seaside blacktop in 90 degree ambient sunshine.  Had to walk on the white stripes at the crosswalk to get to the other side.

Evidently a 140 degree tire is within spec but just what is the spec?  Regardless of the roadway temp I think the mfr must have a top tire temp.  Right?

Camber should give you a temp delta between outside edge and inside and between sides.  What does toe in do to temp on the outside edge?  I know that under inflation increase the tire temp but in the day the tread center of a under inflated tire was cooler than the edges. Same for over loaded.  Race car owners dial in the tire pressure in this manner, or they used to, before they started to monkey around with "push" and "loose" and sway bar tension.  They have been running radials in that arena for 60 years give or take.

This is a great topic.  I have never seen it fully visited here.

John
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: Cary and Don on June 14, 2010, 10:53:39 AM
It seems that on a previous post, it was said that the really important thing was difference in temps between the tires.  We watch that very carefully and have found that a low tire will be hotter than the other tires on the same side.

Don and Cary
GMC4107
Neoplan AN340
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: bobofthenorth on June 14, 2010, 11:21:14 AM
I check my tire temperatures almost every time we stop.  90 to 120 is "normal" but I don't think the absolute temperature means anything.  All I'm looking for is temperature variances which point to tire pressure differences.  Side to side differences of over 20 degrees are common on a sunny day.
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: BG6 on June 14, 2010, 11:24:20 AM
Temps will also vary depending on tire composition, construction, tread pattern, vehicle weight distribution, road camber, road material, how smooth the road is, how much wind and where it's coming from, alignment . . .

All you are really looking for is a "flyer," a tire which is radically outside the temp range of the others.
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: JohnEd on June 14, 2010, 12:26:07 PM
What is the max temp a tire can operate at.  Not "in".....but "at".  BOTN reads 90 to 120 all around so hat is the temp at which we should say....gotta slow down OR WTH????

My mind runs to the guy that has the thermo gun and an air compressor at home and uses the same air pressure gauge for all the bus work.   It is reading 25 pounds low and in the winter or at low speed local trips he sees no problem.  One summer day he stops after a 70 MPH run and while stopped he shoots the tires.  230 F but they are all pretty much even....no fliers.  230 or XXX? is where he should panic and say "not even one more mile!".

We are looking for fliers....agreed.   And we are looking for data that is consistent with history.

john
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: BG6 on June 14, 2010, 12:43:39 PM
Quote from: JohnEd on June 14, 2010, 12:26:07 PM
What is the max temp a tire can operate at. 

230 or XXX? is where he should panic and say "not even one more mile!".

You need to talk to the company that made the tires.  That's the bad news.

The good news is that, on big tires, they are likely to have that information to give you.
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: JohnEd on June 14, 2010, 03:32:47 PM
OK!  Bridgestone North America rep said that a temp of 200 degrees, the actual tire casing, could be sustained safely.  He refused to site a temp at which the tire would be unsafe or the max allowable temp.  He mentioned 200 and it wasn't suggested to him so I would think it represents some kind of barrier.  My tire shop owner said that if I saw temps rise to 200 and pressures and load were within limits he would suggest I park till after sundown or back off the 110 MPH speed.  No joke there.


I don't know that that resolves much.  It wa mentioned that some of the low speed, non hi-way, tires intended for local use will self destruct at hi-way speeds in summer temps.  Brand and design and materials must have a serious bearing.  It came up that the "transition region" where the tread belts and the casing plies meet is most often the hottest part of the tire.

John 
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: Ed Hackenbruch on June 14, 2010, 04:28:47 PM
I check my tire temps at stops, but since i have a pressure pro, i can check the tire pressure any time i want by pushing a button.  ;D
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: BG6 on June 14, 2010, 04:56:27 PM
Quote from: Ed Hackenbruch on June 14, 2010, 04:28:47 PM
I check my tire temps at stops, but since i have a pressure pro, i can check the tire pressure any time i want by pushing a button.  ;D

Useful, but not a protection.  The temp that counts is between the case and the tread, and it can go way up before the pressure will change.
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: Ed Hackenbruch on June 14, 2010, 05:13:26 PM
True, but the temp can go up very quickly in just a matter of a few miles if you start losing air.  :)
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: rv_safetyman on June 14, 2010, 05:32:05 PM
BG6, your last post just does not make sense to me.  I spent 34 years in the rubber industry, some associated with our tire program and I just can't figure out what your thesis is.

There are a ton of studies about tire failure (most done by credible universities).  They clearly and universally find that low pressure causes the vast majority of tire failures.  I have viewed studies that have the percentage as high as 92%, but none lower than 82%.  

I have seen tires at considerable under-inflated condition with only slightly elevated temperatures.  I have a very strong conviction that tire temperature is not a strong indicator of tire pressure unless the tire is under-inflated by at least 25% and run in that condition for many miles (that condition will indicate significant damage).  It can be an indicator of a damaged spot on a tire ****IF**** you could scan the WHOLE tire.  We used to have a really neat tire test dyno that would do just that (very advanced technology at the  time).  

Your thesis seems to be that somehow the tire generates a temperature that affects pressure.  That is only significant from a cold start to operating temperature and then temperature has a very insignificant impact on pressure.

Like many folks I check my tire AND hub temperatures at each stop.  Once in a while I will not use the temp gun, but rather my hand.  The human hand is a pretty good thermometer up to 140*.  Most humans can lay their hand on something that is 140* and not feel pain that would have you remove it smartly.  Folks who do a lot of welding or work with hot objects can sometimes go to 150*.  Like others, my tire run less than 120* almost all of the time.  I do this inspection as a verification that the tire is not experiencing some type of internal failure that is not related to tire pressure.

Just to repeat myself, tire temperature is a nice piece of information, but not a good indicator of tire pressure problems.  Anyone with a properly functioning tire pressure monitor system ***AND*** whose tires were properly inflated during the installation process (sets the baseline for deflation warning),  should feel very confident that they have the highest probability of not having a catastrophic tire failure.    That assumes that the tire has sufficient ratings for the application and that the installation pressure was based on weight at each tire location.

I hope this is taken not as being argumentative, but rather a strong defense of a very important safety device.

Folks, I have edited this post several times and I still don't think I have properly conveyed my understanding of the subject, but it is time to "let it go"

Jim
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: JohnEd on June 14, 2010, 06:03:33 PM
Jim,

The BG stuff aside, do you think BOTN and I are wasting our time by checking temps at rest and meal stops?

I once fond a wheel bearing going out because the hub was a little warm to the touch and that check will stay with me until someone comes up with a better one.  I know it works.

Thanks,

John
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: rv_safetyman on June 14, 2010, 06:20:57 PM
JohnEd, a safety inspection is NEVER a waste of time.  When I walk around the bus I try to use almost all of my senses (vision/smell/touch/hearing) looking anything is abnormal.  Only sense I leave out is taste.  We used to have a compounder (chemist who comes up with the rubber formulas) who could bite a piece of rubber and tell you what synthetic family it came from (neoprene, HBNR, butyl, etc) ::)

As I said in my convoluted previous post, I do it religiously at every stop even though I have the TPMS.  And I stop a bunch since I drink a lot of coffee in the morning and then water to make sure I don't get dehydrated ;) ;).  

Besides we all need the small amount of exercise we get in the walk around.  Also helps the circulation in the legs.  

Just plain win/win.

Jim
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: muddog16 on June 14, 2010, 06:23:04 PM
Being a former racer, I've got a question here?  Where on the tires are you checking the temps?    With a temp gun while racing we checked the tires at the tread  in  three spots across the tires you would be surprised what that tells you its common to have three different temps adjancent to each other on the same tire!   If the tire was over inflated the center temp would be higher, and if it was under inflated it would actually run cooler than the out sides!   There are many factors that come into tire temps!   Also I agree with Jim.........checking the hub temps is probably just as important as the tire temps!
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: JohnEd on June 14, 2010, 06:35:41 PM
Quote from: muddog16 on June 14, 2010, 06:23:04 PM
Being a former racer, I've got a question here?  Where on the tires are you checking the temps?    With a temp gun while racing we checked the tires at the tread  in  three spots across the tires you would be surprised what that tells you its common to have three different temps adjacent to each other on the same tire!   If the tire was over inflated the center temp would be higher, and if it was under inflated it would actually run cooler than the out sides!   There are many factors that come into tire temps!   Also I agree with Jim.........checking the hub temps is probably just as important as the tire temps!

HALALUHYA!!!!!!!

I say that and all I get is stone silence.  I knew I wasn't sucking all that out of my thumb.  When I was hanging around the pits they had a fast reacting contact thermometer  that they tested the tire with.

Dog,  Is this sort of testing still valid with modern radials?  I would be "surprised" cause it has been so long ago and I forget far better than I used to.  Can you refer to any pub/reference that discusses tire temps and indications?
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: rv_safetyman on June 14, 2010, 06:37:35 PM
Pat, I used to use a temp gun on the blower belts on top fuel cars in the shutdown area as a part of my "blower belt guy" assignment.  I started checking the tires for the drivers.  In this case I did much the same as you did.  Not nearly as indicative because of the tire growth that drag racing tires are designed to have, but it did get the guys to checking the tires as a part of their database.

I check the tires about 2-3 inches below the tread on the side wall.  The tread temperature is not all that important on a truck or bus, since we are not looking for temp differential across a rather narrow tire.  In racing, it can help you optimize tire pressure, but on a truck or bus, the tire pressure should be based on the tire rating for the weight on that tire.

The reason I check the tire in that location is that it lets me measure all the tires in the same location - including the inside dual.  Also, we are looking for excessive fatigue in the sidewall.  The 2-3 inches below tread can be done on most inside duals easily and fairly accurately measures the sidewall temp.
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: happycamperbrat on June 14, 2010, 06:49:53 PM
Wow! You people are running a LOT lower temps then my bus. I live in the truely HOT though, typical summer day is 110 degrees. Last summer I would drive and check my tire temp often with a temp gun. They were running around 145 degrees. Goodyear tires, rated for the highway.
Title: Re: Tire Temperature
Post by: rv_safetyman on June 14, 2010, 07:05:29 PM
hcb, I don't think your temps are all that high for the conditions. 

"Rusty" on this board has tire temperatures that are well above that (can't recall exactly what he told me, but it blew me away) and he has not had a problem after a ton of miles.  And that is at much more reasonable ambient temperatures.  We have talked extensively and his tires are properly rated and inflated.  We will be making a trip to the Eagle Rally next month and I will use my gun to verify his temperatures, but our discussions have me believing he does indeed have some pretty high temperatures.

Most rubber products are cured in the low 200* range for a half an hour or so (depending on the product shape and volume).  They continue to cure at a rate that is a function the internal temperature.  A few posts back someone mentioned a tire person had talked about 200* as an upper temperature.  I would have a stroke if my tires got within 40* of that temperature but that is just me and my paranoia.

Jim